Books and Documents

Islamic Ideology (29 Jan 2017 NewAgeIslam.Com)

Can A Muslim Ever Be Anti-Semitic?


By Rashid Samnakay, New Age Islam

28 January 2017

Around the Mediterranean coast almost all countries and those of the Middle East are supposed to be Semitic people speaking Arabic and other Semitic languages, such as Hebrew language that the Jews consider as their religious and national language, and therefore they all are counted as Semitic people.

For the Muslim nation as a whole, which considers Saudi Arabia, the cradle of Islam and the birth place of Messenger Muhammad, a samite, cannot by any stretch of imagination be branded as anti-Semitic. That would be thoroughly blasphemous. Therefore to say that Muslims, as followers of the faith Islam are anti-Semitic is compounding the felony since they, just as the Jews claim to be of the “nation of Ibrahim” because they follow the faith established by Aba Abraham, long before Moses and Muhammad were born.

Today anti-Semitism is exclusively taken as “hating the Jews”. In Europe, both the West and the East, which is not Semitic, hatred of Jews and persecution is well-documented history and well established practice of anti-Semitism there; culminating in the holocaust of six million Jews. The word holocaust is therefore exclusively applied today to the elimination policy of Jews in Germany, a European country and not a North African, Middle Eastern country, or Palestine. The later, country which gave the Jews sanctuary since Moses time!

Let us commemorate today, along with the Jews, the victims of that dreadful event called the holocaust, perpetrated in Europe!

The Christian Church in general and Catholic Church in particular have been scathing of Jews on religious ground and critical of its Zionist manifestation, till very recently. It was in our lifetime that Pope John Paul II who should be thanked for reversing the well-established Jew-hating culture of Europe.

There were very many people on both sides of the argument-fence, supporting or condemning the Jews/Zionists. But their actions, since the formation of the State of Israel are a bone of contention. There are even famous people who deny the holocaust, unbelievable as it may seem!

Such condemnation has in some quarters taken the form of hatred of Jews and can be considered as anti-Semitic but to generalise any legitimate criticism of Israel, its creators, its supporters as anti-Semitisms, is brattish, a sign of immaturity and a complex of insecurity on the part of Jews.

Zionism is considered by many as apartheid of the old South African kind practiced under the banner of Christianity, racism and colonialism of the worst kind and compared to conquistadors of South America. Expulsion of Palestinians and violence against them has become the hallmark of Zionist Israel. Not surprisingly the Reformed Jews were against the “return” to Palestine on religious pretext.

The Palestinians people as major stake holders were not even consulted and were not included in the negotiation process to grant their land to the Jews. Goodly sounding promises by the powers to be were made and humanitarian pledges given in political statement which were clearly not meant to be honoured and were not ever honoured.

Israel, the Jewish/Zionist State’s insecurity stems from its callous, unthankful and immoral actions of biting the hands that had nourished them with mana from heaven from the time of Moses who sought refuge with his few followers in Palestine, to escape from the brutalities of Pharaoh.

Thus Palestinian nation comprises of many different people including Jews; and Moses followers who settled there later.  Palestine was never a Tera nullius as Zionist would have us believe. So it has never been an exclusive Jewish land to claim as its own. They were settled there under some given conditions – a “covenant” with God which they had broken number of times, hence lost the land as many times.

Recently, after the WWII, in sympathy for the Jews for having suffered persecution at their hands the Europeans felt pangs of conscience and supported the idea of giving the Jews land of their own. Perhaps also expecting as a by-product a solution in it to solve the problems they were causing in their countries. To that effect large piece of land was “offered to them in Uganda or Argentina” as if it was Tera nullius, said historian Professor Ali Mazrui of East Africa; which offer the Jews rejected. They wanted the holy land promised by God in spite of the fact God had bestowed it upon them number of times before and finally withdrew His favour on account of them having broken the “covenant” as many times. God is merciful but He too has His limit for He has to be fair and just!

The persecution of Palestinians by the Israelis is therefore all the more strange. Having been driven from one country to another over centuries, of all the people they should be more understanding of what it means to drive people from their home and hearth. Then also they are the people of the Book and no Book advocates such acts in its true essence. Thankfulness is a virtue. The insecurity of the Zionists is therefore resultant self- generated.

The Palestinians, particularly the land holders and feudal lords are also to be blamed. They sold their lands to the Zionists at asking prices and are enjoying themselves in foreign lands. Now the landless Palestinians are suffering the consequences of the greed, corruption and treachery of the elite. In addition to that the Palestinians are divided amongst themselves and divided people can never succeed to achieve a common goal.

There are other people and foreign nations too involved in maintaining the status quo for their vested interest. It seems that is the politics of the powers on earth.

Criticism of Zionist Israel is valid on many fronts, but to say that this criticism is anti-Semitism on the part of Muslims; as was the case with Catholic Church till recently, is naïve. Particularly in the context of Muslims in general, for they consider the Jews as their brethren in Faith. But the Israelis have adopted the stance that any criticism of Israel is anti-Semitic and immediately draw out that card, or hoist the holocaust flag!

The holocaust did occur; whether six million or six matters not. One does not have to wait for the Jews to displace and kill six million Palestinians for the world to accept it as holocaust. Even one such life taken is genocide of a nation and that is the justification for criticism, irrespective of who perpetrates the crime; Muslims, Semites and non-Semites. Man’s inhumanity to man recognises no boundaries and has not stopped from time immemorial!

Palestine could be and should be the multi-faith Capital State of the so called people of the Book, brethren in faith. If only Moses or Muhammad would reappear to sort this out it would be better for humanity as a whole. But alas neither of them is expected to do so and it is too late and beyond the ken of the likes of Aba Abraham!

The solution must lie in the sincerity of good intentions of those who masquerade as policeman and peace-keepers in the world, to really want to bring Peace on earth. On the contrary they have very obvious agendas of keeping the pot boiling so as never to let the WAR industry go bankrupt. It is bad economics as it causes huge unemployment at home!

While that policy is being implemented, it is self-evident truth that the Palestinians are being slowly but surely annihilated. The recent UN resolution against Israel is evidence of that. The US very kindly did not cast its veto to block it, but as a cowardly gesture abstained from voting for the resolution supported by rest of the world! How strange it is that when others say similar things, it is fair criticism but when a Muslim points it out, it is anti-Semitism and then inevitably other skeletons fall out of the closet.


A regular contributor to New Age Islam, Rashid Samnakay is a (Retd.) Engineer

URL: http://www.newageislam.com/islamic-ideology/rashid-samnakay,-new-age-islam/can-a-muslim-ever-be-anti-semitic?/d/109879

 New Age IslamIslam OnlineIslamic WebsiteAfrican Muslim NewsArab World NewsSouth Asia NewsIndian Muslim NewsWorld Muslim NewsWomen in IslamIslamic FeminismArab WomenWomen In ArabIslamophobia in AmericaMuslim Women in WestIslam Women and Feminism


  • Royalj asks "The question arises; if the Christians can forgive the Jews why can’t the Muslims do it."

    He is quite mixed up in more ways than one. It is the Christians who are in need of forgiveness by the Jews because of which the Pope sought their forgiveness and not the other way round.

    Forgiveness is for past wrongs and not for the present ongoing ones as is the case in the case of the Palestinian people. As far as the present is concerned, what is required for peace is that Israel honour the rights of the Palestinian people and implement the two state solution or give them equal rights as citizens.

    By Naseer Ahmed - 2/2/2017 4:41:18 AM

  • Israel is like a thorn in the throat of every Muslim, unable to spit it out nor to swallow it. Rashid is correct. Christians have swallowed the hatred towards Jews through the effort of Pope John Paul II; who made a visit to Jerusalem and asked forgiveness for the persecutions of the Jews. He placed a letter seeking forgiveness in the Wailing Wall, which is 2035 years old, a remnant of the retaining wall of the original Jewish temple. Christians blamed the Jews for the crucifixion of Christ. When Roman Governor Pilot wanted to save Jesus from death sentence, it was the Jewish Chief Priest and majority of Jews who demanded crucifixion. Pilot took water and washed his hands in front of the crowd. “I am innocent of this man’s blood, it is your responsibility” he said. All the Jews answered “HIS BLOOD IS ON US AND ON OUR CHILDREN’ (Mathew 27:24-25)

    Many believe that this blood curse on themselves, was the reason that the Jews became refugees all over the world without a country of their own as Romans destroyed Jerusalem and the great Temple in 70 A.D.

    The question arises; if the Christians can forgive the Jews why can’t the Muslims do it. Definitely world will be in peace. Lest Middle East can be a cause for Third World War.


    By Royalj - 2/2/2017 2:27:14 AM

  • Donald Triumph is not mad, islamists should judge their international status and weight.
    By U.p. Ojha - 1/31/2017 11:59:01 AM

  • dear Aayina
    kindly do a search on you tube as well as google for middle eastern tv talk shows, call-in programs, panel discussion along with key words for your particular search.

    as there is a tendency among the moderate people on this forum to label everything embarrassing or inconvenient either as being islamophobic or as having been taken from islamophobic sites - no matter from where they are quoted or cited.

    there are media watch dog groups all over the world. every one watches everyone else's media, twitter feeds, facebook posts and contents of other social media platforms.

    google has been a good friend to me. i am sure he will be yours too. but just try to cross-check everything.


    By hats off! - 1/31/2017 12:49:52 AM

  • Whatever the origins, the task for us is to try to rid ourselves of all prejudice and bigotry. I must, by the way, commend the excellent work of the Anti-Defamation League. American Jews are in the forefront of the fight against the anti-Muslim bias of the Trump administration.

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 1/30/2017 1:11:22 PM

  • Read a good book on the history of the Jews under Islam, Hats Off, rather than getting all your knowledge from Islamophobic sites. If there are fewer Jews today in Muslim countries, it is because they have migrated for better opportunities or to serve their own country Israel. There are far more of every nationality in the US today than 200 years earlier and they are not all refugees but migrants seeking better opportunities..

    By Naseer Ahmed - 1/30/2017 8:43:08 AM

  • Hatts off Can you post those khutbas, which has Jews hatred.

    I see myself and Hindus from jewes point of view, we Hindus have only one land in entire world technically, Pakistan and his sister Bangladesh had nearly finished 13% Hindus.

    This is the case all over the world where Muslim come as political power does not matter it is by heridatory or democracy, in 50-60 years whole non-Muslim(a Muslim degarotary certificate)  nearly kind of vanishish.

    Except old India where Hindu and Sikh Kings were constantly battling, so was not able to convert or kill Indians large population.

    By Aayina - 1/30/2017 5:23:34 AM

  • Anti-Semitism has been around since the Christians accused the Jew Judas of having betrayed Christ.

    From that beginning it eventually found its way into the Holy Qur'an (for example 5:82 and also other verses). It ultimately resulted in the banishment of all Jews from the Hejaz. People have such conveniently short memories.

    Now most of the Islamic lands are remarkable free of Jews. Almost a miraculously convenient thing.  They have virtually disappeared from Iran, Iraq, Syria, and from all of North Africa.

    In Pakistan, (the first Islamic republic) at the time of partition, there were sizeable numbers. Now it has just one. Give or take dozen.

    As of today Jews are migrating fast from France, Germany, Sweden, Norway and Switzerland. Almost all the universities of Europe and north America are rife with anti-Semitic BDS student bodies, anti-Jewish Palestinian as well as Muslim special interest student groups, the regressive leftist liberal student groups and groups of other simple minded morons who think that one cannot be a liberal unless one hates the guts of the Jews and curse Israel.

    The Sahih Bukhari Hadees were written much before the 1967 war. Even the bible was written well before the 1967 war.

    During the Second World War the waffen-ss 13th division was a Bosnian Muslim division and were a documented part of the holocaust in Hungary.

    To call anti-Semitism non-existent before the 1967 war is wilful blindness or brazen lying.

    Ever since the Jews refused to accept Jesus and later the prophet of Islam as one of their Prophets, ant-Semitism has been a part and parcel of Christian as well as Muslim religious discourse.

    I can oblige you by posting links to some of the Jewsiest TV talk shows, Khutbas and Islamic sermons if you have the heart for it. The latest is just two days old.

    By hats off! - 1/30/2017 4:21:02 AM

  • Antisemitism did not exist before the 1967 war but has taken very strong roots since then. It is very much like Islamophobia - based on half truths, outright lies, fabrication of myths and denial of facts.

    By Naseer Ahmed - 1/30/2017 2:35:04 AM

  • While Arabs too are a semitic people, the word "anti-semitism" has come to mean anti-Jewish prejudice. 

    Criticizing the policies of Israel is not necessarily anti-Semitic. Aspersing the innate nature or character of the Jewish people is anti-Semitic.

    By Ghulam Mohiyuddin - 1/29/2017 1:48:26 PM

Compose Your Comments here:
Email (Not to be published)
Fill the text
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the articles and comments are the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect that of NewAgeIslam.com.